Latest

Read the latest on our policy campaigns, victories, and more. Please direct all media inquiries to mediarequests@bds.org.

Testimony: The New York City Council Committee on Immigration Oversight Hearing on Sanctuary Protections for Immigrant Communities

Brooklyn Defender Services told the City Council that New York must strengthen its sanctuary protections as immigrant New Yorkers face rising risks of detention, deportation, and family separation. In testimony before the Committee on Immigration, BDS warned that unlawful information-sharing, weak agency training, and expansive city data systems can funnel people into federal immigration enforcement even when local law is supposed to protect them. “The city cannot adequately protect New Yorkers, or uphold the detainer discretion laws, without upholding the requirement that ICE present a judicial warrant in interactions with City agencies about an individual for the purpose of civil immigration enforcement,” said Sophie Dalsimer Associate Director, New York Immigrant Family Unity Project. BDS urged the Council to close gaps in the detainer law, improve agency compliance, limit sensitive data collection, and pass the NYC Trust Act so New Yorkers harmed by violations can hold the city accountable.
Letters & Testimonies
Immigration Raids & Detention

Press Release: Federal Court Blocks Significant Pieces of Administration’s Sweeping Immigration Appeals Rule That Eliminates Meaningful Judicial Review

Brooklyn Defender Services joined immigrant rights organizations in a federal lawsuit challenging a Trump-Vance administration rule that would have gutted meaningful review at the Board of Immigration Appeals and sharply increased the risk of wrongful deportations. A federal court has now blocked key parts of that rule, preserving immigrants’ ability to appeal removal decisions before they are deported. The challenged rule would have slashed the deadline to file most appeals from 30 days to 10 and made summary dismissals far easier, threatening due process for people fighting to remain with their families and communities. “Today’s ruling preserves a vital avenue for judicial review in removal proceedings,” said Lucas Marquez, Director of Civil Rights & Law Reform at Brooklyn Defender Services.
Press Releases
Right to Counsel in Immigration Court

Testimony: The New York City Council Committees on Oversight and Investigation and Criminal Justice Oversight Hearing on the Department of Investigation’s Reports on Agency Compliance with Sanctuary-related Local Laws

Brooklyn Defender Services advised the City Council Committees on Oversight and Investigation and Criminal Justice Oversight that New York City must strengthen and enforce its sanctuary laws to stop city agencies from becoming conduits for detention and deportation. In testimony on agency compliance with sanctuary-related laws, BDS pointed to recent findings that city staff shared information with federal immigration authorities and warned that weak training, poor oversight, and unlawful data-sharing continue to put immigrant New Yorkers at risk of family separation and prolonged detention. “The city cannot adequately protect New Yorkers, or uphold the detainer discretion laws, without upholding the requirement that ICE present a judicial warrant,” said Sophie Dalsimer, Associate Director of the New York Immigrant Family Unity Project.
Letters & Testimonies
Immigration Raids & Detention

Testimony: The New York City Council Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use Oversight Hearing on the From Crisis to Care: How New York City Connects New Yorkers to Mental Health Services.

Brooklyn Defender Services told the City Council that New Yorkers in mental health crisis are still too often met by police instead of care, leading to escalation, arrest, and incarceration when people need treatment. In testimony before the Council’s Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use, BDS called for a stronger health care response to crisis, more low-cost mental health and substance use treatment, expanded housing access, and culturally competent services that people can actually reach before they end up in court. “Mental health crises must be treated as health issues, not law enforcement matters,” said Danielle Regis, Senior Supervising Attorney, Mental Health Representation Team.
Letters & Testimonies
Mental health

Testimony: New York City Council Committee on Technology Oversight Hearing on Facial Recognition Technology and the Collection of Biometric Data

Brooklyn Defender Services recommended that the New York City Council take steps to rein in biometric surveillance and pass bills that would limit the use of facial recognition and other biometric data collection in residential buildings and places of public accommodation. In testimony before the Council’s Committee on Technology, Talia Kamran, Staff Attorney & Fellow, Seizure and Surveillance Defense Project, Criminal Defense Practice, warned that these systems do not make New Yorkers safer. They expose people to privacy violations, discriminatory targeting, false arrests, and government access to deeply personal data, with the heaviest burden falling on Black, brown, and heavily policed communities. BDS also argued that the Council must go further by confronting the city’s own use of surveillance tools, from jail voiceprint databases to the NYPD gang database, which can deepen criminalization and family separation, "There is no way to build a humane surveillance state."
Letters & Testimonies
Surveillance and Civil Rights

Testimony: The New York City Council Committee on Children and Youth Subject: Examining Racial Disparities in New York City’s Family Policing System and the Need for Family Miranda Rights

Brooklyn Defender Services joined other New York City family defense organizations to urge the City Council to pass legislation requiring “Family Miranda Rights” at the first point of contact between ACS and families. In testimony before the Committee on Children and Youth, the organizations detailed stark racial disparities in the family policing system and called for immediate action to ensure parents are informed of their rights and have timely access to counsel before invasive investigations escalate to family separation. “When families know their rights and are able to effectuate them they stay safe and intact,” said Nila Natarajan, Director, Family Defense Practice and Policy.
Letters & Testimonies
Early Defense for Parents Facing ACS Investigations

Testimony: The New York City Council Committees on Public Safety and Small Business Oversight Hearing on Retail Theft

Testifying before a City Council oversight hearing on retail theft, Attorney-in-Charge of Law Reform and Policy Gina Mitchell urged lawmakers to reject expanded surveillance and punitive responses that criminalize poverty and instead invest in housing, mental health care, and youth employment. City data show retail theft has returned to pre-pandemic levels, yet proposals before the Council would spend millions on cameras and policing rather than address the affordability crisis and untreated behavioral health needs driving many cases. “These policing measures do not address the affordability crisis or social issues that are driving most cases of retail theft,” Mitchell testified, calling on the Council to fund services that stabilize communities and reduce system involvement at its root.
Letters & Testimonies
Surveillance and Civil Rights

Press Release: Parents Sue New York Over Unconstitutional Delays In Process To Challenge Their Harmful Listings On Child Maltreatment Registry

Brooklyn Defender Services joined the Family Justice Law Center, the Center for Family Representation, the NYU Family Defense Clinic, Sullivan & Cromwell LLP, and others to file a federal class action lawsuit challenging unconstitutional delays in New York’s process for appealing listings on the State’s child abuse and maltreatment registry. Thousands of parents are forced to wait more than a year to clear their names even though most ultimately succeed, while being blocked from jobs in health care, education, and child care and prevented from caring for relatives. “As public defenders, we see firsthand the harm a parent’s SCR indicated report can have on a family—from a parent losing a long-standing job, to reduced employment opportunities and the inability to be a family support system for loved ones in crisis,” said Lauren Shapiro, Managing Director of the Family Defense Practice. “New York families deserve a fair and timely process when they seek to appeal their inclusion on the SCR.”
Press Releases
Early Defense for Parents Facing ACS Investigations

Press Release: Legal Services Organizations Sue to Block Sweeping Immigration Appeals Rule That Eliminates Meaningful Judicial Review

Brooklyn Defender Services joined Amica Center for Immigrant Rights, the Florence Immigrant & Refugee Rights Project, HIAS, the American Immigration Council, and the National Immigrant Justice Center in filing a federal lawsuit to block a sweeping new rule that would dismantle meaningful appeals in immigration court. The rule would drastically shorten appeal deadlines, allow cases to be dismissed before transcripts are even created, and make it far harder for people facing deportation to challenge legal errors in their cases. “The Interim Final Rule creates a barrier to appellate review in removal proceedings and strikes at the heart of due process,” said Lucas Marquez, Director of Civil Rights & Law Reform at BDS. “The Rule will result in the deportation of people who are eligible for immigration relief...simply because the Board of Immigration Appeals will no longer be an avenue to fairly review their cases.”
Press Releases
Immigration Raids & Detention

Testimony: The New York City Council Committees on Criminal Justice Oversight Hearing on Programming to Prevent Recidivism and Promote Public Health and Safety

At a City Council oversight hearing on jail programming, Senior Jail Services Attorney Michael Klinger testified that years of funding cuts and staffing failures have left people on Rikers without meaningful access to education, therapy, and reentry programs which undermines public safety and successful returns to the community. While the city recently restored some funding for nonprofit providers, too many people in custody still face canceled classes, missed escorts, and barriers to school enrollment, including young people legally entitled to education and adults eager to earn a GED. "Providing excellent programs will support successful re-entry and at the same time increase safety and security in the jails."
Letters & Testimonies
Bail & Pre-Trial Incarceration

Content Types

Issues

Practice Areas